Name: Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar
Address: 61 S Van Buren St, Nashville, Indiana, 47448, US
Telephone: +1 812-200-1999
Price range: $10-20

Welcome to Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar

Experience the finest dining

Nestled in the heart of Nashville, Indiana, Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar welcomes diners to experience a blend of classic American flavors and unique culinary twists. The restaurant thrives on its friendly atmosphere and attentive service, creating a comforting space for both locals and visitors. Guests rave about the tenderloin sandwich and ribeye steak, while the expansive menu offers something for everyone, from meatball hoagies to flatbread pizzas. Whether you're stopping by for a leisurely lunch, an inviting dinner, or a late-night snack, this spot guarantees delicious meals and prompt seating, even during peak hours. Located at 61 S Van Buren St, this culinary haven invites you to unwind and indulge in its appetizing offerings with loved ones.

Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar shines with an array of features designed to elevate any dining experience. The cozy interior sets a welcoming tone, while the menu boasts over 20 delectable dishes, showcasing a diverse selection of favorites such as the Cuban sandwich and Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. Regulars appreciate the prompt seating, even on bustling Saturdays when the restaurant hits full capacity at 3 PM. Access to high-quality meats is evident in dishes like the breaded pork tenderloin and ribeye steak. The bar area invites patrons to unwind with an assortment of local brews and crafted cocktails, adding an extra layer of enjoyment. Each bite is made with care and attention to detail, ensuring that every visit is memorable, whether it’s a family gathering or a casual catch-up with friends.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

61 S Van Buren St, Nashville, IN 47448, United States

Phone

+1 812-200-1999

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar is more than just a restaurant; it’s a cornerstone of Nashville, Indiana’s vibrant culinary scene. Established with the goal of offering high-quality American cuisine, it has quickly become a go-to dining destination. The owners prioritize local ingredients, crafting dishes that reflect both tradition and innovation. The menu features satisfying classics like the iconic tenderloin sandwich, renowned for its tender meat and flavorful seasonings, which have garnered rave reviews from customers.

Likewise, the ribeye steak stands out for its juiciness and depth of flavor, ensuring that carnivores leave satisfied.

The ambiance of the restaurant radiates warmth, making it perfect for gatherings of all kinds. Friends and families find comfort in the familiar décor and friendly staff who aim to provide a delightful dining experience. For special occasions or casual outings, the restaurant’s diverse menu ensures that each guest finds something to love.

The owners’ commitment to service excellence is evident in the praise received for prompt seating and attentive staff. Children can enjoy selections from the menu tailored for younger appetites, while adults indulge in hearty portions of satisfying American fare.

Each week, Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar welcomes both regulars and newcomers to explore a menu enriched with flavors, allowing visitors to experience true Midwestern hospitality. Located conveniently along bustling Van Buren St, it’s easy to drop in whether you’re a local or just passing through.

With busy peak times on weekends, the restaurant manages to maintain quality and service, creating a lively but relaxed atmosphere suitable for any occasion. In a town known for its charm, this restaurant is a must-visit for those hungry for delicious food and a taste of local culture.

The exterior of Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar presents a welcoming visage, marked by rustic charm that invites guests to step inside. The façade blends modern touches with traditional elements, reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to both quality and comfort. Outdoor seating options allow patrons to soak in the beautiful Nashville weather while enjoying their meal, perfect for those sunny afternoons or starry evenings. This vibrant local eatery buzzes with energy, often filled with the sounds of laughter and the tantalizing aroma of grilled meats and delicious sauces wafting through the air. The vibe is informal yet lively, making it an ideal spot to relax after a day of exploring the scenic trails around Nashville.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

SundayClosed
Monday11 AM-8 PM
Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
Thursday11 AM-8 PM
Friday11 AM-9 PM
Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We LOVE Out of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar! Their pork tenderloin was SO good and huge! It has a fun atmosphere with lots of exposed wood and green plants. The staff was super friendly and our waiter was fantastic! I absolutely recommend stopping by if you're in the area.

Callie M.

The staff are very friendly and helpful.. makes this restaurant feels like visiting family. The food is great, I would recommend the fettuccine with steak. Wow!

P M.

Came to Nashville for my bachelorette party, where we decided to dress up as hillbillies and go out to dinner. We chose out of the ordinary, and before we even entered the restaurant we were greeted by amazing staff, and an awesome waiter who handled a group of 7 drunk girls acting like rednecks AMAZINGLY. Everyone was so kind and inviting, the food was good too. If you're in Nashville on a girls trip, or for any reason, and you need a place with a fun, laid back atmosphere, I highly recommend!

Audrie B.

Out of the Ordinary - Nashville, IN Out of the Ordinary is a delightful spot in the heart of Nashville, IN, offering hearty, flavorful dishes with a welcoming atmosphere. Their pork tenderloin is a standout--perfectly cooked, juicy, and generously portioned, it's a must-try for anyone who loves a classic Midwest favorite. The onion rings are crisp and golden, providing the perfect accompaniment, and the generous portion of pulled pork is rich, tender, and bursting with sweet and smoky goodness. One of the most impressive aspects of this restaurant is their attention to dietary needs. They offer a special Alpha-gal menu, a thoughtful inclusion for those with this specific allergy. Additionally, they have no problem accommodating dairy-free adjustments, making it a stress-free dining experience for those with dietary restrictions. With its inviting vibe, great service, and creative approach to ensuring everyone can enjoy their meal, Out of the Ordinary lives up to its name in the best way possible!

Thalia T.

We ate dinner last night here, food was excellent, tenderloin was huge, my daughter and I shared, steak and potatoe soup was delicious. And Darian our waitress was so attentive and gracious, excellent waitress.

Bonnie P.

The food was excellent and the service even better! Our server not only knew what she was doing, she knew what we were thinking before we did. Tasha was fantastic!

Wendell J.

Out Of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar